ملخص الدراسة:

This study addresses the narrators whom the Imam Ibn Hajar criticized (Taqub) Ibn Qania, Ibn Al Jawzi, Al Saji, Ibn Abdulbir,and Ibn Hazm former sayings about in his book (A Taqreeb) (critical comparative study). I have displayed a brief definition of Imam Ibn Hajar, and (Al Taqub), in language and idiomatically, and have worked hard to learn the most correct of sayings of these Imams about every narrator, through a critical comparative study between their sayings, and the statements of other critics, and then I have placed a summary of each of these narrators which clarifies the judgment of the narrator on what I see as preponderant, whether it is the view of one of them, or the view of one of the other critics, in an abbreviated clear statement, this was after the post-critical study comparing everything mentioned about every one of these nine narrators. I have concluded this research including the most important findings and recommendations.

توثيق المرجعي (APA)